So, this morning I am once again thankful for the early hours of a new day, with the melodic sound of birdsong filling my ears whilst I clunk away at the keys on my keyboard. There is something rather special about these quiet moments, before the day gets going and the demands of life begin to compete for our attention. This morning, though, my mind was wrestling with a question. I found myself wondering why I was drifting and what was drawing my attention elsewhere. Rather than simply brushing the thought aside, I decided to do what Scripture encourages us to do: ask, seek and knock. After spending some time turning the question over in my mind, I found myself back at something I have been thinking about for a while. Music, and what kind of music we should be allowing into our lives as Christians.
I am not
looking to start an argument about musical preferences. We all have our likes
and dislikes, and I am certainly no exception. But I do think it is worth
asking whether we have sometimes allowed our personal preferences to become
something more than that. Does the genre of music really matter to God? Does He
have a preferred sound, or have we perhaps imposed restrictions on Christian
music that Scripture itself does not establish?
I have
heard the arguments. Some believe that praise and worship should be accompanied
by little more than an organ or a piano. Others are quite comfortable with
guitars, drums and a much wider range of instruments. Then there are those who
prefer traditional hymns, while others enjoy contemporary worship, gospel or
even Christian rock. I understand that people have different tastes. What I am
interested in, however, is what the Word of God actually says and teaches us.
If I am going to form an opinion on something that concerns my walk with God, I
would rather have Scripture as my starting point than simply follow what
someone else believes.
When I read
about David and the people of Israel celebrating before God in 1 Chronicles
13:8, I find an interesting picture. They were singing and playing lyres,
harps, tambourines, cymbals and trumpets. There was certainly no shortage of
instruments. Psalm 150:3-5 also calls upon the people to praise God with
trumpets, harps, lyres, tambourines, stringed instruments, pipes and cymbals. I
cannot read those passages and come away believing that praise has been
restricted to one particular instrument or musical arrangement.
There is
something we should remember, though. Enthusiasm and good intentions are no
substitute for obedience. Whatever we do, our approach must remain subject to
God's Word. Perhaps that is where we should begin when considering music. Not
with the instruments, not with the genre, and certainly not with whether we
happen to enjoy the sound. Paul writes:
“Let
the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in
all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in
your hearts to God.” Colossians 3:16 (ESV).
That is
something I have always tried to remember in my songwriting. The Word of Christ
is not an afterthought in my lyrics. Biblical accuracy has always been my first
priority. I do not want to write something simply because it sounds good or
because a chorus might catch someone's attention. I want the words to mean
something, to communicate truth, and to stand up to Scripture. I want them to
challenge thinking, encourage faith, and point people towards Jesus Christ. I
write the lyrics, and through Rafe Dust those words find their voice and
musical expression. The sound and arrangement may vary, but the message must
never stray from the truth of God's Word.
When I look
at the people God used in Scripture to write songs, I am reminded that music
has always been a way of expressing what God has done. Moses wrote a song and
taught it to the children of Israel, as we read in Deuteronomy 31:22. The song
itself, recorded in Deuteronomy 32, reminded the people of God's faithfulness
and their own history. David's songs came from his life experiences. He wrote
about fear, danger, deliverance, repentance and thanksgiving. Psalm 18 is one
such example, a song of deliverance in which David declares, "I love you,
O LORD, my strength" (Psalm 18:1). These were not merely words put
together to make a pleasant sound. They came from a life that had experienced
God's faithfulness.
We also
read in 1 Samuel 16:14-23 that David played the harp before Saul when an evil
spirit troubled him. Saul was refreshed and felt better. I would not suggest
that this passage ascribes independent spiritual power to music, but it does
remind us that music can affect us deeply. We know this from our own
experiences. A song can bring back memories, comfort us in difficult moments,
or remind us of something we may have forgotten.
Then there
is Paul and Silas, sitting in prison with their feet in stocks, yet still
praying and singing hymns to God (Acts 16:25). Think about that for a moment.
They were not in a church; no congregation gathered around them, and their
circumstances were hardly ideal. Yet they sang. Their praise was not dependent
on everything going well. It came from a faith that endured even when life was
difficult. I find that a powerful reminder of what music can be when it comes
from the heart.
But I also
need to be careful here. I am not suggesting that anything goes, or that a
Christian label automatically makes a song suitable. The words matter. The
message matters. What we choose to listen to and allow to influence our
thinking matters. First Corinthians 10:31 reminds us that whatever we do, we
should do it all to the glory of God. That includes the music we make and the
music we listen to. A catchy melody cannot make an unbiblical message right,
just as a beautiful arrangement can disguise words that misrepresent God.
At the same
time, I think we should be careful not to confuse personal preference with
biblical instruction. There is a difference between saying that I do not enjoy
a particular style of music and saying that God does not approve of it. The
first is an opinion. The second is a claim that must be supported by Scripture.
Romans 14 gives us principles for matters of conscience and warns us against
judging one another where God has not given us a specific command. It does not
deal directly with musical genres, but it does remind me to be cautious about
turning my own preferences into rules for everybody else.
Paul also
writes in 1 Corinthians 14:15, "I will sing with the spirit, and I will
sing with the understanding also." That is worth reflecting on. Music can
stir our emotions, and there is nothing wrong with being moved by a song. But
do we understand what we are singing? Do we know what the words mean? Are they
faithful to Scripture? I would rather sing something that prompts me to pause
and consider the truth it expresses than simply enjoy a chorus without giving
any thought to its message.
So, where
does that leave me with the question, I woke up thinking about this morning?
I keep
coming back to the same thing. My lyrics are about my testimony, my life, and
my giving thanks to a faithful Redeemer. They come from my experiences,
failures, questions, and understanding of Scripture. Above all, they come from
a desire to acknowledge what God has done in my life. Rafe Dust gives those
words musical and vocal expression, but the foundation of what I write remains
the same. I want the message to be true. I want it to honour God and point
people towards Christ.
Perhaps we
sometimes spend so much time debating the sound of Christian music that we
overlook what is actually being said. We can become so concerned about whether
a song has a piano, an organ, a guitar or drums that we forget to examine the
words. Yet surely that is where our attention should begin. Is the message
faithful to Scripture? Does it encourage truth? Does it glorify God? These are
questions worth asking, regardless of musical style.
As I sit
here listening to the birds outside, I am reminded that God's creation is
filled with sounds and expressions we could never begin to reproduce. The birds
are not singing hymns, nor are they following a human definition of Christian
music. Yet their song reminds me of the One who made them. It has brought me
back to the question, perhaps also to a simpler way of looking at it.
I do not
believe the genre should be our primary criterion for judging whether music is
pleasing to God. I believe we should first look at the heart behind it, the
truth within it, and whether it brings honour to Him. That does not mean
abandoning discernment or accepting everything without question. It means
allowing the Word of God to set the boundaries, rather than assuming that our
own musical preferences are His commandments.
I think that is where I have landed this morning. I am
still asking questions, and I am quite comfortable with that. But one thing I
do know: I want whatever words I put to paper, whatever musical expression
gives them life, and whatever testimony they communicate to remain faithful to
the One who has given me reason to write in the first place.
Signing off
Tyrone
Related passages: 1
Chronicles 13:8-10; 1 Chronicles 15:13; Psalm 150:3-5; Colossians 3:16;
Ephesians 5:19; 1 Corinthians 10:31; 1 Corinthians 14:15.